Difference between revisions of "Comparison/English"
m (→Comparison table) |
m (→reordered columns) |
||
Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
!License / Source | !License / Source | ||
!OS | !OS | ||
+ | !Noise canceling | ||
+ | !Overlay | ||
+ | !Positional audio <sup id="fn_2-1_back">[[#fn 2-3|3]]</sup> | ||
+ | !Skins | ||
!Opus Codec | !Opus Codec | ||
!CELT Codec | !CELT Codec | ||
Line 18: | Line 22: | ||
!GSM Codec | !GSM Codec | ||
!Other Codecs | !Other Codecs | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
|[[GameVox]] | |[[GameVox]] | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | Commercial / Closed <sup id="fn_2-2_back">[[#fn 2-2|2]]</sup> | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | Commercial / Closed <sup id="fn_2-2_back">[[#fn 2-2|2]]</sup> | ||
| Windows | | Windows | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Server Themes | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
Line 31: | Line 35: | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
|| No | || No | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Main_Page|Mumble]] | |[[Main_Page|Mumble]] | ||
Line 42: | Line 42: | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
− | |||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | || No | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[TeamSpeak 2.x]] | |[[TeamSpeak 2.x]] | ||
| bgcolor=#ffffdd | Free Client, Commercial / Closed <sup id="fn_2-1_back">[[#fn 2-1|1]]</sup> | | bgcolor=#ffffdd | Free Client, Commercial / Closed <sup id="fn_2-1_back">[[#fn 2-1|1]]</sup> | ||
| Windows, Linux, Mac OS X | | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffffdd | External | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffffdd | Modified files | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
Line 57: | Line 61: | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
|| Yes | || Yes | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
|[[TeamSpeak 3.x]] | |[[TeamSpeak 3.x]] | ||
| bgcolor=#ffffdd | Free Client, Commercial / Closed <sup id="fn_2-1_back">[[#fn 2-1|1]]</sup> | | bgcolor=#ffffdd | Free Client, Commercial / Closed <sup id="fn_2-1_back">[[#fn 2-1|1]]</sup> | ||
| Windows, Linux, Mac OS X | | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
Line 70: | Line 74: | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
|| Yes | || Yes | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Ventrilo]] 2.x | |[[Ventrilo]] 2.x | ||
Line 80: | Line 80: | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffffdd | < 2.3.x | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
+ | || Yes | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Ventrilo]] 3.x | |[[Ventrilo]] 3.x | ||
Line 93: | Line 93: | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
+ | || Yes | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[VoiceChatter]] | |[[VoiceChatter]] | ||
| bgcolor=#ddffdd | Free / Open | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Free / Open | ||
| Windows, Linux, Mac OS X (Intel only) | | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X (Intel only) | ||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | || No | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Mohawk Voice]] | |[[Mohawk Voice]] | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | Commercial / Closed | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | Commercial / Closed | ||
| Windows | | Windows | ||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ddffdd | Yes | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | || No | ||
|- | |- | ||
|[[Skype]] | |[[Skype]] | ||
| bgcolor=#ffffdd | Free / Closed | | bgcolor=#ffffdd | Free / Closed | ||
| Windows, Linux, Mac OS X<sup id="fn_2-4_back">[[#fn 2-5|5]]</sup> | | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X<sup id="fn_2-4_back">[[#fn 2-5|5]]</sup> | ||
− | |||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
− | |||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
+ | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | No | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
| bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | | bgcolor=#ffdddd | ? | ||
+ | || Yes<sup id="fn_2-4_back">[[#fn 2-4|4]]</sup> | ||
|- | |- | ||
|} | |} |
Revision as of 11:59, 26 October 2013
Notice: This page is a stub. |
We are still working over this page. Please be patient. |
Comparison table
Name | License / Source | OS | Noise canceling | Overlay | Positional audio 3 | Skins | Opus Codec | CELT Codec | Speex Codec | GSM Codec | Other Codecs |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
GameVox | Commercial / Closed 2 | Windows | Yes | Yes | No | Server Themes | Yes | No | No | No | No |
Mumble | Free / Open | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X, iPhone | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No |
TeamSpeak 2.x | Free Client, Commercial / Closed 1 | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X | No | External | No | Modified files | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
TeamSpeak 3.x | Free Client, Commercial / Closed 1 | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X | Yes | ? | ? | ? | ? | Yes | Yes | ? | Yes |
Ventrilo 2.x | Free Client, Commercial / Closed 2 | Windows | No | No | No | No | No | No | < 2.3.x | Yes | Yes |
Ventrilo 3.x | Free Client, Commercial / Closed 2 | Windows, Mac OS X | No | No | No | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
VoiceChatter | Free / Open | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X (Intel only) | No | No | No | No | ? | No | Yes | No | No |
Mohawk Voice | Commercial / Closed | Windows | No | No | No | No | ? | No | Yes | No | No |
Skype | Free / Closed | Windows, Linux, Mac OS X5 | ? | ? | ? | ? | No | No | ? | ? | Yes4 |
- 1: The TeamSpeak client is free to download. Hosting a server for free is limited.
- 2: Ventrilo is free for personal/non commercial usage with some limitations.
- 3: You hear your teammates as though they are speaking from their relative position in-game.
- 4: Skype uses proprietary codecs. More recent versions use SILK.
- 5: The Linux and OS X clients offered by Skype offer limited functionality compared to the Windows client, and are updated far less frequently.
Video
- Latency Tests
- Ventrilo vs Teamspeak 3 vs Mumble
- Mumble vs Ventrilo Latency Test (YouTube Video)
- Mumble vs. TS2, Ventrilo - Transmission Delay (Latency) (YouTube Video)